Choosing between the Triumph Thruxton RS and the Speed Twin can be a tough call, especially if you're a fan of classic British motorcycles. Both bikes offer a blend of style, performance, and heritage that's hard to resist. But, they also cater to slightly different riders and riding styles. Let's dive deep into a detailed comparison to help you figure out which one deserves a spot in your garage.

Overview of Triumph Thruxton RS

The Triumph Thruxton RS is the quintessential café racer, embodying a blend of classic aesthetics and modern performance. It's designed for riders who appreciate a more focused and engaging riding experience. The Thruxton RS stands out with its aggressive stance, sporty ergonomics, and a host of premium components that enhance both its performance and visual appeal. Let's delve deeper into what makes this bike a standout in the modern classic category.

Key Features and Specs

When it comes to key features, the Thruxton RS doesn't hold back. At its heart lies a potent 1200cc liquid-cooled, parallel-twin engine, meticulously tuned to deliver a thrilling 105 horsepower and 83 lb-ft of torque. This engine isn't just about raw power; it’s about delivering that power in a smooth, linear fashion that’s accessible and engaging for riders of all skill levels. The engine’s responsiveness is further enhanced by its ride-by-wire throttle system, which ensures precise and predictable control.

Beyond the engine, the Thruxton RS boasts a high-spec chassis that contributes significantly to its sporty handling. Fully adjustable Showa Big Piston forks at the front and Öhlins rear suspension units allow riders to fine-tune the bike's suspension to their specific preferences and riding conditions. This level of adjustability is a boon for riders who demand optimal performance, whether they're carving through twisty mountain roads or cruising down the highway. Braking performance is equally impressive, with Brembo M50 radial monobloc calipers providing powerful and consistent stopping power. These brakes, combined with the bike's ABS system, inspire confidence and ensure safety in various riding situations.

Design and Styling

The design and styling of the Thruxton RS are where it truly shines as a café racer. The bike's silhouette is defined by its low-slung profile, muscular fuel tank, and distinctive seat cowl, all of which pay homage to the classic café racers of the 1960s. However, Triumph hasn't just replicated the past; they've infused the Thruxton RS with modern touches that elevate its aesthetic appeal. The brushed aluminum finishes on the tank strap, Monza-style fuel cap, and stainless steel exhaust system exude quality and attention to detail. These premium materials not only look great but also contribute to the bike's overall sense of refinement.

The attention to detail extends to the Thruxton RS's cockpit, where riders are greeted by a pair of elegant analog gauges that provide essential information at a glance. These gauges are complemented by a small digital display that offers additional data such as riding mode, gear position, and trip information. The riding position is sporty and purposeful, with clip-on handlebars that encourage a forward lean, placing the rider in an optimal position for spirited riding. While this riding position may not be ideal for long-distance touring, it's perfect for attacking winding roads and feeling connected to the bike.

Riding Experience

The riding experience on the Thruxton RS is nothing short of exhilarating. The bike's potent engine delivers ample power and torque throughout the rev range, making it a joy to ride in various conditions. Whether you're accelerating out of corners, overtaking on the highway, or simply cruising around town, the Thruxton RS always feels responsive and eager to please. The bike's sporty chassis and premium suspension components contribute to its precise and predictable handling. It corners with confidence and stability, inspiring riders to push their limits and explore the bike's full potential.

The Thruxton RS also benefits from a suite of electronic rider aids that enhance both safety and performance. These include multiple riding modes (Road, Rain, and Sport), traction control, and ABS. These systems work seamlessly in the background to provide an extra layer of confidence, particularly in challenging riding conditions. Overall, the riding experience on the Thruxton RS is a blend of classic charm and modern performance, making it a truly special motorcycle that appeals to riders who appreciate both style and substance.

Overview of Triumph Speed Twin

The Triumph Speed Twin is a modern classic roadster that blends timeless design with contemporary performance. It's designed to offer a more versatile and accessible riding experience compared to the Thruxton RS, making it an excellent choice for riders who value both style and practicality. The Speed Twin stands out with its comfortable ergonomics, nimble handling, and a host of modern features that enhance its overall usability. Let's dive deeper into what makes this bike a standout in the modern classic category.

Key Features and Specs

When it comes to key features, the Speed Twin offers a compelling package that balances performance and practicality. At its heart lies a responsive 1200cc liquid-cooled, parallel-twin engine, tuned to deliver a smooth and engaging riding experience. While it may not have the same peak horsepower as the Thruxton RS, the Speed Twin's engine offers plenty of torque throughout the rev range, making it a joy to ride in various conditions. The engine's responsiveness is further enhanced by its ride-by-wire throttle system, which ensures precise and predictable control.

Beyond the engine, the Speed Twin boasts a well-sorted chassis that contributes to its nimble handling. The bike's suspension is designed to provide a comfortable and controlled ride, whether you're navigating city streets or carving through twisty roads. Up front, you'll find cartridge forks that offer a good balance of compliance and support, while the rear suspension features twin shocks with adjustable preload. This level of adjustability allows riders to fine-tune the bike's suspension to their specific preferences and riding conditions. Braking performance is equally impressive, with Brembo brakes providing strong and consistent stopping power.

Design and Styling

The design and styling of the Speed Twin are where it truly shines as a modern classic roadster. The bike's silhouette is defined by its clean lines, muscular fuel tank, and comfortable seating position, all of which pay homage to the classic roadsters of the past. However, Triumph hasn't just replicated the past; they've infused the Speed Twin with modern touches that elevate its aesthetic appeal. The brushed aluminum finishes on the tank badges, headlight brackets, and side panels exude quality and attention to detail. These premium materials not only look great but also contribute to the bike's overall sense of refinement.

The attention to detail extends to the Speed Twin's cockpit, where riders are greeted by a pair of stylish analog gauges that provide essential information at a glance. These gauges are complemented by a small digital display that offers additional data such as riding mode, gear position, and trip information. The riding position is upright and comfortable, with a wide handlebar that provides excellent leverage and control. This riding position is ideal for a variety of riding situations, from commuting to weekend rides.

Riding Experience

The riding experience on the Speed Twin is a blend of classic charm and modern performance. The bike's responsive engine delivers ample power and torque throughout the rev range, making it a joy to ride in various conditions. Whether you're accelerating out of corners, overtaking on the highway, or simply cruising around town, the Speed Twin always feels responsive and eager to please. The bike's nimble chassis and well-sorted suspension contribute to its confidence-inspiring handling. It corners with ease and stability, inspiring riders to explore the bike's full potential.

The Speed Twin also benefits from a suite of electronic rider aids that enhance both safety and performance. These include multiple riding modes (Road, Rain, and Sport), traction control, and ABS. These systems work seamlessly in the background to provide an extra layer of confidence, particularly in challenging riding conditions. Overall, the riding experience on the Speed Twin is a blend of classic charm and modern performance, making it a truly special motorcycle that appeals to riders who appreciate both style and substance.

Performance Comparison

When comparing the Triumph Thruxton RS and the Speed Twin in terms of performance, it's essential to consider their distinct design philosophies and intended use cases. Both bikes share the same 1200cc parallel-twin engine, but each model has been tuned to deliver a unique riding experience. The Thruxton RS, with its café racer DNA, prioritizes outright performance and a more focused riding experience, while the Speed Twin aims for a balance of performance and everyday usability.

Engine and Power

In terms of engine and power, the Thruxton RS edges out the Speed Twin with its slightly higher output figures. The Thruxton RS boasts 105 horsepower and 83 lb-ft of torque, while the Speed Twin produces around 97 horsepower and 82 lb-ft of torque. While the difference in peak power may not seem significant on paper, it translates to a noticeable difference in real-world performance. The Thruxton RS feels more responsive and eager to rev, especially at higher RPMs, making it a thrilling ride for those who enjoy spirited riding.

The Speed Twin, on the other hand, delivers its power in a smoother and more linear fashion. Its engine is tuned to provide ample torque throughout the rev range, making it a joy to ride in various conditions. Whether you're accelerating out of corners, overtaking on the highway, or simply cruising around town, the Speed Twin always feels responsive and tractable. The Speed Twin's engine is also more forgiving and easier to manage, making it a great choice for riders who prioritize comfort and usability.

Handling and Suspension

When it comes to handling and suspension, the Thruxton RS takes the lead with its premium components and sporty chassis. The Thruxton RS features fully adjustable Showa Big Piston forks at the front and Öhlins rear suspension units, allowing riders to fine-tune the bike's suspension to their specific preferences and riding conditions. This level of adjustability is a boon for riders who demand optimal performance, whether they're carving through twisty mountain roads or hitting the track.

The Speed Twin offers a more compliant and comfortable ride, thanks to its well-sorted suspension and balanced chassis. The Speed Twin's suspension is designed to soak up bumps and imperfections in the road, providing a smooth and controlled ride. While it may not offer the same level of adjustability as the Thruxton RS, the Speed Twin's suspension is more than capable of handling a variety of riding conditions. The Speed Twin's chassis is also more forgiving and easier to manage, making it a great choice for riders who prioritize comfort and confidence.

Braking

In terms of braking, both the Thruxton RS and the Speed Twin offer excellent stopping power. The Thruxton RS features Brembo M50 radial monobloc calipers, which provide powerful and consistent braking performance. The Speed Twin also features Brembo brakes, which offer strong and reliable stopping power. Both bikes are equipped with ABS, which provides an extra layer of safety and confidence in challenging riding conditions.

Comfort and Ergonomics

Comfort and ergonomics are crucial factors to consider when choosing between the Triumph Thruxton RS and the Speed Twin, as they significantly impact the overall riding experience, especially on longer journeys. These two models cater to different rider preferences and styles, with the Thruxton RS leaning towards a sportier, more aggressive posture, and the Speed Twin offering a more relaxed, upright position.

Riding Position

The Thruxton RS adopts a classic café racer riding position, characterized by its low-slung clip-on handlebars and rear-set footpegs. This setup encourages a forward lean, which enhances the rider's connection to the bike and provides a more engaging feel during spirited riding. However, this posture can put more strain on the wrists, back, and shoulders, making it less comfortable for extended periods or daily commuting. While the Thruxton RS's riding position is ideal for short, intense rides, it may not be the best choice for those who prioritize long-distance comfort.

In contrast, the Speed Twin offers a more relaxed and upright riding position, thanks to its higher handlebars and neutrally positioned footpegs. This setup allows for a more natural and comfortable posture, reducing strain on the rider's body and making it easier to control the bike at low speeds. The Speed Twin's riding position is well-suited for a variety of riding situations, from commuting to weekend rides, and is a great choice for riders who value versatility and all-day comfort.

Seat Comfort

The Thruxton RS features a sculpted seat that is designed to provide support and comfort during spirited riding. However, the seat is relatively firm and narrow, which may not be ideal for longer journeys. The Thruxton RS's seat is also positioned higher than the Speed Twin's, which can make it more challenging for shorter riders to reach the ground.

The Speed Twin offers a more comfortable and accommodating seat, thanks to its wider and more generously padded design. The Speed Twin's seat provides ample support for riders of all sizes and is well-suited for long-distance riding. The Speed Twin's seat is also positioned lower than the Thruxton RS's, which makes it easier for shorter riders to reach the ground and feel confident in traffic.

Style and Aesthetics

Style and aesthetics are highly subjective factors, but they play a significant role in the appeal of the Triumph Thruxton RS and the Speed Twin. Both bikes embody the essence of modern classic motorcycles, but they do so with distinct design cues and personalities. The Thruxton RS exudes a sporty, aggressive aura, while the Speed Twin presents a more understated, refined appearance.

Design Elements

The Thruxton RS is characterized by its classic café racer silhouette, featuring a low-slung profile, sculpted fuel tank, and a sporty seat cowl. It showcases premium materials such as brushed aluminum finishes, Monza-style fuel cap, and stainless steel exhaust system. These elements combine to create a visually stunning motorcycle that pays homage to the golden age of British racing.

The Speed Twin adopts a more contemporary and minimalist design language. It features clean lines, a muscular fuel tank, and a comfortable seating position. The Speed Twin showcases subtle yet elegant details such as brushed aluminum finishes, stylish tank badges, and a well-integrated lighting system. These elements contribute to a sophisticated and timeless aesthetic.

Which One is Right for You?

Choosing between the Triumph Thruxton RS and the Speed Twin ultimately depends on your individual preferences, riding style, and priorities. If you're a rider who values outright performance, sporty handling, and a classic café racer aesthetic, the Thruxton RS is an excellent choice. However, if you prioritize comfort, versatility, and a more relaxed riding experience, the Speed Twin may be the better option.

Consider These Factors

• Riding Style: Do you prefer spirited rides on twisty roads or relaxed cruises on the open highway?
• Comfort: How important is comfort for your daily commute or long-distance touring?
• Aesthetics: Which design appeals more to your personal taste?
• Budget: Are you willing to spend extra for premium components and performance-oriented features?

By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision and choose the Triumph that best suits your needs and desires. Safe riding, guys!