Hey pizza lovers! If you're anything like me, you live and breathe for that perfect slice. The crispy crust, the gooey cheese, the tangy sauce… chef’s kiss! And if you're in New York City, you're in the absolute pizza capital of the world, am I right? But with so many options, where do you even begin? That's where the internet (and more specifically, Reddit) comes in clutch. Reddit, as we all know, is the ultimate source of truth, especially when it comes to food. So, I dove deep into the NYC pizza threads, devoured countless recommendations, and emerged with the ultimate rundown of the most famous pizza joints in NYC, according to the wise people of Reddit. Get ready to drool, because we're about to embark on a delicious journey through the heart of NYC pizza culture.

The OG's: Iconic NYC Pizza Institutions

Let's kick things off with the heavy hitters, the pizza places that have earned their legendary status over decades. These are the spots you have to try, the places that practically ooze history and flavor. The first place we're hitting up is Lombardi's, located in Little Italy. Lombardi's holds the prestigious title of being America's first pizzeria, opening its doors way back in 1905. Reddit users frequently sing its praises, often highlighting the classic, no-frills approach to pizza. They stick to the basics, using fresh ingredients and a coal-fired oven to create a simple yet incredibly satisfying pizza experience. Expect a thin, slightly charred crust, a bright tomato sauce, and a generous layer of mozzarella. It's a true taste of history and a must-visit for any pizza pilgrim.

Next up, we have John's of Bleecker Street, a Greenwich Village institution that's been around since 1929. John's is another coal-oven pioneer, and their pizzas are known for their incredibly flavorful crusts. What sets John's apart, according to the Reddit community, is their commitment to the entire pie. You cannot order by the slice; you can only get a whole pie. So, gather your crew, because you're gonna want to share this masterpiece. Reddit users rave about the perfectly balanced flavors and the consistently excellent quality. Be prepared for a wait, especially during peak hours, but trust me, it’s worth it. The cozy, old-school atmosphere adds to the charm. Walking into John's feels like stepping back in time, and the pizza is a testament to why some traditions are worth preserving.

Finally, we can't forget Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano on Coney Island. Founded in 1924, Totonno's is another family-run establishment with a fiercely loyal following. This place is famous for its simple, high-quality ingredients and its dedication to the Neapolitan style of pizza making. Many Redditors appreciate the slightly less-charred crust compared to some coal-fired pizzerias, finding it easier to eat the whole pie. The sauce is bright and flavorful, and the cheese is always perfectly melted. Unfortunately, Totonno's is currently closed, but it's worth keeping an eye on for when they reopen, because they are a cornerstone of NYC pizza history. The history here is just as important as the taste.

Modern Marvels: New-School Pizza Giants

While the OGs are undoubtedly important, the NYC pizza scene is constantly evolving, with new places popping up and pushing the boundaries of what pizza can be. These are the spots that are innovating, experimenting, and winning over the hearts (and stomachs) of the Reddit community. First up, we have Paulie Gee's, with locations in Greenpoint and the West Village. Paulie Gee's is known for its creative and innovative pizzas, often featuring unique toppings and combinations. Reddit users love their attention to detail, their high-quality ingredients, and their commitment to wood-fired cooking. The crust is always perfectly crisp, the toppings are always fresh, and the pizzas are always bursting with flavor. The Hellboy (with soppressata and Mike's Hot Honey) is a Reddit favorite, and for good reason! Paulie Gee's also offers a variety of vegan options, making it a great choice for everyone. Paulie Gee is a true artist, and the pizza reflects that.

Next, we have Roberta's Pizza, located in Bushwick. Roberta's is famous for its wood-fired pizzas, its hipster vibe, and its bustling atmosphere. Reddit users love the crispy, slightly charred crusts, the creative topping combinations, and the overall experience. The Bee Sting (with honey and chili flakes) is a crowd-pleaser, and the simple Margherita is always a safe bet. Roberta’s isn’t just about the pizza; it's about the entire experience. It's a place to hang out, grab a beer, and enjoy some seriously good pizza with friends. It’s got that cool, Brooklyn vibe that everyone loves. The community here is vibrant, just like their pizzas.

Then, we have Lucali, in Carroll Gardens. This place is infamous for its extremely limited seating and its no-reservations policy. But the pizza? Oh, the pizza is worth the wait. Lucali serves a simple, yet stunningly delicious, pizza with a thin crust, fresh mozzarella, and a light tomato sauce. Reddit users rave about the quality of the ingredients and the simplicity of the approach. It's pizza perfection. It is a very coveted place, and just landing a table is a feat in itself. But once you're there, you'll understand the hype. The pizza is worth the effort, the wait, and the potential frustration. It's a true hidden gem, if you can get in.

Slice of Heaven: The Best Pizza by the Slice

Sometimes, you don't have time for a whole pie. Sometimes, you just need a quick, delicious slice to satisfy your cravings. Luckily, NYC has some incredible options for pizza by the slice. First up is Joe's Pizza, with multiple locations throughout the city. Joe's is a classic, no-frills pizzeria that serves up a consistently excellent slice. Reddit users love the simple, New York-style slice with a perfectly balanced crust, sauce, and cheese. It's the kind of slice you can grab and go, and it never disappoints. It's a reliable choice and a true staple of NYC pizza culture. You know you're always getting a good slice when you go to Joe’s.

Next, we have Artichoke Basille's Pizza, also with multiple locations. Artichoke is famous for its unique and decadent slices, particularly the artichoke heart slice. Reddit users rave about the creamy, cheesy, and flavorful slices. Artichoke is the go-to place when you want something a little more adventurous. It's a great option for those who want to step outside of the traditional pizza box. Artichoke's unique slices are a must-try. Their innovative approach to toppings makes them a favorite among Redditors. You can always count on a delicious, over-the-top slice here.

Lastly, we have 2 Bros Pizza, found all over the city. 2 Bros is known for its affordable and reliable slices, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious pizza lovers. Reddit users appreciate the consistently good quality and the convenience. It’s a great option when you're on a tight budget or just need a quick and easy slice. It’s definitely a solid choice for a quick bite. 2 Bros is the epitome of classic, affordable NYC pizza. They keep it simple, and they keep it delicious.

Reddit Wisdom: Tips for Your Pizza Adventure

So, you’re ready to embark on your NYC pizza adventure? Here are some pro-tips gleaned from the collective wisdom of Reddit:

• Go early or late: Avoid the crowds by going to popular pizzerias before or after peak lunch and dinner hours. The pizza is just as good, and you'll save yourself some serious waiting time.
• Embrace the whole pie: Some places, like John's of Bleecker Street, only sell whole pies. Gather your friends, or be prepared to take some leftovers home.
• Do your research: Check the hours of operation and make reservations if possible, especially for popular places. A little planning goes a long way.
• Don't be afraid to try new things: Experiment with different toppings, crusts, and styles. You might just discover your new favorite pizza.
• Most importantly: have fun! Pizza is meant to be enjoyed. Savor every bite, and embrace the NYC pizza experience.

Conclusion: The Slice of Life

NYC pizza is more than just food; it's a culture. It's a symbol of the city itself: diverse, vibrant, and always evolving. Whether you're a seasoned pizza aficionado or a first-timer, there's a slice out there waiting for you. Use this Reddit rundown as your guide, explore the city, and discover your own favorite pizza places. From the iconic institutions to the modern marvels, the options are endless. So, grab a slice, take a bite, and experience the magic of NYC pizza for yourself. Happy eating, pizza lovers! Remember, in the words of Reddit itself, “The best pizza is the one you’re eating!” So get out there, explore, and find your own slice of heaven.